Evaluation of the Support Programme for the Reconstruction of Housing and Neighbourhoods in Haiti
Mid 2012-end 2014, for UN-Habitat
Groupe URD is carrying out a new iterative evaluation in Haiti concerning post-earthquake urban reconstruction policy. The subject of the evaluation is the Support Programme for the Reconstruction of Housing and Neighbourhoods which has been implemented by Haitian institutions, with support from UN agencies. The programme, initiated and coordinated by UN-Habitat, is steered by UCLBP, Unité de Construction du Logement et des Bâtiments Publics, a new Haitian institution. In order to provide support throughout the duration of the programme, the evaluation involves three field visits (2012, 2013 and 2014), and is complimented by the activities of Groupe URD’s Haiti Observatory.
The earthquake of January 2010 claimed a huge number of lives and destroyed a very large number of houses in the Haitian capital, Port-au-Prince, and in other areas of the south-east of the country, considerably weakening the capacities of the Haitian Government. Following the wave of international aid that took place, and the influx of a large number of organizations and programmes, it quickly became clear that it would be complicated to coordinate all the projects implemented throughout the territory. A Support Programme for the Reconstruction of Housing and Neighbourhoods was therefore developed under the aegis of the Haiti Interim Reconstruction Commission (HIRC), which has since been dissolved in accordance with its temporary mandate, in partnership with the relevant ministries and UN-Habitat.
As a large number of projects and operations have been carried out in parallel, using different approaches, in several neighbourhoods of Port-au-Prince and in the other towns affected, the evaluation will speak to both institutional and aid institutions and will test, coordinate and share lessons for a common methodology to support the reconstruction of housing and neighbourhoods.
This Support Programme was conceived to meet the challenges that were identified during the numerous coordination meetings and discussions which took place following the deployment of international in the different clusters: Shelter, CCCM, Protection, Food Security, Livelihood and Early Recovery. It emerged from these Cluster Meetings that the humanitarian sector was having difficulty coping with the unprecedented scale of damage, the enormous need for aid and the number of actors, as well as the specific characteristics of the urban environment. UN-Habitat therefore organised workshops based on the notion of Housing and Neighbourhoods, which then led to the Support Programme for the Reconstruction of Housing and Neighbourhoods.
This programme is in keeping with the objectives of UN Joint Programmes, which are the result of the UN Reform and which have been implemented in an innovative way in Haiti. It involves different UN agencies: the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) and UN-Habitat, which is responsible for its general coordination and the Technical Secretariat for the Unité de Construction du Logement et des Bâtiments Publics, which is the Haitian body in charge of the project.
The Support Programme has four inter-related components which are co-directed by pairs of organisations made up of Haitian institutional bodies and UN agencies.
The Programme was designed to pool information and coordinate efforts to manage information by the different coordination bodies in order to optimise their actions in the longer term and to provide them with basic decision-making tools.
The principle of an iterative evaluation is to analyse how a programme is being implemented in relation to changes in context and needs, and to ensure that the programme remains relevant and that there is effective coordination between the actors involved.
The evaluation in Haiti :
- Identify whether the main objectives have been achieved and analyse the impacts and the effectiveness of the programme ;
- Make recommendations annually which allow the programme to be adjusted, by identifying the different factors of change to the institutional logic, as well as the coordination between the 4 components, the problems and need for interaction in order to ensure that there is synergy between the mechanism’s activities.
In order to provide support throughout the evolution of the programme, Groupe URD proposed that this assignment should take the form of an iterative evaluation, with a field visit each year in 2012, 2013 and 2014. The field visits in 2012 and 2014 involve interviews with partners and the interim field visit in 2013 takes the form of a collective seminar-workshop for all the Programme partners.
Between these annual field visits, Groupe URD’s office in Port-au-Prince monitors a certain number of key meetings based on the evolution of the programme and the context, in connection with the Haiti Observatory.